Rangers’ Young Stars: One Rising, One Falling—A Tale of Two Futures in the NHL’s Harsh Reality of Survival of the Fittest!

by

Rangers’ Young Stars: One Rising, One Falling—A Tale of Two Futures in the NHL’s Harsh Reality of Survival of the Fittest!

Noah Laba and Brennan Othmann represent two divergent paths within the New York Rangers organization, highlighting the stark realities of professional sports where talent alone does not guarantee success. At just 22 years old, both players are at critical junctures in their careers, yet their trajectories could not be more different. Laba, a fourth-round draft pick in 2022, has emerged as a surprising asset for the Rangers, while Othmann, a first-round pick from 2021, finds himself struggling to find his footing in the NHL.

Laba’s recent performance has been nothing short of impressive. He scored his first two NHL goals in a single week and earned a promotion to the top six during a road trip that included games against formidable opponents like the Seattle Kraken and Edmonton Oilers. His ability to adapt and thrive in high-pressure situations has caught the attention of both the coaching staff and fans alike. Coach Mike Sullivan has praised Laba’s maturity and aptitude for the game, noting that his development is evident with each game he plays. Laba’s commitment to a well-rounded game—showing skill on both offense and defense—has made him a valuable player for the Rangers.

In contrast, Othmann’s journey has been fraught with challenges. After being called up to the NHL due to an injury to teammate Matt Rempe, he played only one game before being sent back to the Hartford Wolf Pack of the American Hockey League. His time in the NHL has been marked by missed opportunities and defensive lapses, including a critical mistake that led to a goal against the Calgary Flames. Sullivan has expressed concerns about Othmann’s lack of attention to detail and predictability on the ice, which have hindered his ability to earn a consistent spot in the lineup.

The differences in their situations raise questions about the development processes within professional sports organizations. Laba’s rapid ascent can be attributed to a combination of hard work, adaptability, and a supportive coaching staff that recognizes his potential. His performance has not only earned him a place on the roster but has also allowed him to contribute meaningfully to the team’s success. The Rangers’ recent victories, particularly during the road trip, underscore the importance of having players who can step up and perform under pressure.

On the other hand, Othmann’s struggles highlight the harsh realities of professional sports, where even highly touted prospects can falter. Despite his undeniable skill set, his inability to translate that talent into consistent performance at the NHL level raises concerns about his future with the team. The Rangers’ decision to send him back to the AHL is not merely a punitive measure; it reflects a desire to see him gain valuable experience and work on the aspects of his game that need improvement. Sullivan’s comments suggest that the organization still believes in Othmann’s potential, but it is clear that he must address his shortcomings to regain the trust of the coaching staff.

The contrasting narratives of Laba and Othmann serve as a microcosm of the broader challenges faced by young athletes in professional sports. The pressure to perform is immense, and the margin for error is razor-thin. For every player who rises to the occasion, there are others who struggle to adapt to the demands of the league. The Rangers’ current situation underscores the importance of not only talent but also the mental fortitude and work ethic required to succeed at the highest level.

As the season progresses, the Rangers will be closely monitoring both players’ developments. Laba’s continued success could solidify his role as a key contributor, while Othmann’s path back to the NHL will depend on his ability to learn from his experiences and make the necessary adjustments. The organization must navigate these challenges carefully, balancing the immediate needs of the team with the long-term development of its young players.

In the world of professional hockey, where the stakes are high and the competition is fierce, the stories of Noah Laba and Brennan Othmann serve as a reminder of the unpredictable nature of sports. Their journeys reflect not only their individual talents but also the broader themes of perseverance, growth, and the relentless pursuit of excellence that define the NHL landscape. As fans and analysts alike watch their careers unfold, the question remains: who will ultimately rise to the occasion, and who will fade into the background?

Why 2 young Rangers forwards are heading in opposite directions
Blake Dahlin-Imagn Images

Noah Laba and Brennan Othmann couldn’t be much further apart in their current standing with the New York Rangers. Where one young forward is a pleasant surprise and NHL regular, the other is seeking to earn trust and rebuild his game in the minor leagues.

The difference between the 22-year-olds right now is striking. Laba, a 2022 fourth-round draft pick, scored his first two NHL goals this past week and earned a promotion into the top six on the just-completed road trip to western Canada and Seattle. Othmann spent the past week in the NHL and played one game after Matt Rempe landed on IR with an upper-body injury. He was sent back to Hartford of the American Hockey League on Sunday.

After practice Monday, Rangers coach Mike Sullivan wasn’t asked by reporters to compare the two youngsters, whose careers right now are traveling in separate lanes. But how he answered unrelated questions about each spoke volumes about how the coach currently views Laba and Othmann.

When asked about whether Laba’s surprisingly mature play at center allowed the Rangers to load up their top line with Mika Zibanejad, J.T. Miller, and Artemi Panarin in the final two games of the trip, a pair of overtime wins against the Seattle Kraken and Edmonton Oilers, Sullivan didn’t hesitate to heap praise on the rookie.

“100 percent. One of the things that allowed us to do it is the traction we’re seen with ‘Labs’ in his overall game on both sides of the puck. He’s improving and growing and developing right in front of our eyes with every game that he plays,” Sullivan gushed. “His learning curve has been steep. He’s got real good aptitude for the game, and so I think that’s been a big part of it. And if we didn’t have a comfort level there, we probably wouldn’t do it.”

Laba had an outstanding training camp and forced his way on to the Rangers’ opening-night roster. He did so despite just 11 games of pro experience in the AHL late last season after finishing up at Colorado College.

Though Laba’s had some expected ups and downs to start his NHL career, he clearly has the trust of the coaching staff and his teammates. He plays a committed 200-foot game, is smart, fast, and hard to play against. In another words, he’s Sullivan’s kind of player.

Laba’s played all 13 games, averaging just under 12 minutes TOI, has four points (two goals, two assists), and won 54.7 percent of his face-offs. The past two games he moved up from the third line to center one in the top six, where he’s flanked by Alexis Lafreniere and Will Cuylle. And it’s Laba bringing out the best in his more experienced and well-known linemates.

“He’s just playing with so much confidence, and he’s hungry, you know?” Sullivan said over the weekend. “The most impressive thing for me is his composure.”

Brennan Othmann’s defensive shortcomings among ‘subtleties’ that concern Rangers

NHL: Vancouver Canucks at New York Rangers
Danny Wild-Imagn Images

Confidence — or lack thereof — is a big issue for Othmann, As is his lack of attention to detail defensively, per Sullivan.

In other words, the coach trusts Laba and doesn’t have the some level of faith in Othmann. Play away from the puck is something coach and player discussed repeatedly since training camp, and was the main reason given when Othmann was cut and sent to Hartford in late September.

It didn’t help Othmann that he made a glaring missed assignment defensively that led to a goal for the Calgary Flames in a 5-1 road loss last week. Not surprisingly, Othmann was replaced by veteran Jonny Brodzinski in the Rangers lineup the final three games of the trip. The Rangers won each of those games and Othmann was sent back to Hartford.

“‘Otter’ has NHL skill, without a doubt. I think it’s a lot of the subtleties, and that was the discussion I had with him,” Sullivan said Monday.

That’s not even taking into account that Othmann’s yet to score in 26 NHL games, spread over three seasons.

Predictability and reliability are words Sullivan uses often when discussing Othmann’s shortcomings, and did so again Monday.

But don’t think that the coach is burying the 2021 first-round pick, who scored 21 goals as a rookie pro with Hartford two season ago. Even if there’ve been recent trade rumors involving Othmann, Sullivan presented a big picture reason for sending the forward back to the minors.

“The other part of it is we don’t want a player, especially a young player, sitting on the sidelines,” Sullivan explained. “He was on the West Coast trip with us, he played one of the games. We would rather see him get into game action, so he has an opportunity to learn through those experiences. And that’s part of it also. He’s a young player, he’s got a lot of his career in front of him.”

Related Headlines

Leave a Comment