Luigi Mangione’s Prison Playlist: A Disturbing Reflection of Pop Culture’s Absurdity in the Face of Violence and Crime
The case of Luigi Mangione, an alleged murder suspect, presents a striking intersection of crime, culture, and societal fascination that has captivated the public’s attention. Arrested for the shocking murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson outside a Manhattan hotel, Mangione has spent nearly a year in the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn, where he has become something of a cultural phenomenon. His situation raises complex questions about the nature of celebrity, the role of music in prison, and the public’s appetite for sensational narratives surrounding crime.
Mangione’s recent revelation that he listened to music by pop icons Charli XCX and Taylor Swift while incarcerated adds an extra layer of intrigue to his story. In a leaked letter written to an undisclosed recipient, he reflects on his experiences in prison, including a moment of self-discovery sparked by the music of two of the most prominent figures in contemporary pop. Notably, he expressed curiosity about their music after seeing a “phony list” of his favorite songs circulating on social media, indicating a desire to engage with popular culture even from behind bars.
This phenomenon of inmates consuming mainstream music is not new. Music has long been a source of solace and escapism for those in confinement. It serves to bridge the gap between the harsh realities of prison life and the outside world, offering a semblance of normalcy. For Mangione, the act of downloading songs by Swift and XCX was not merely a musical exploration but a means of connecting with a culture that he felt alienated from due to his circumstances. However, this mundane act took a turn when he was confronted by another inmate, ‘King,’ who scolded him for his choices and subsequently replaced his music with tracks from Lil Durk. This interaction underscores the complex social hierarchies that exist within prison environments, where musical preferences can serve as markers of identity and belonging.
The intersection of crime and pop culture has been a recurring theme throughout history, with infamous figures often becoming subjects of fascination. Mangione’s case has sparked a wave of interest online, leading to discussions about potential film adaptations and documentaries. The idea of casting actors like Dave Franco to portray him highlights society’s tendency to romanticize or sensationalize criminal narratives, transforming real-life tragedies into entertainment. Franco himself has acknowledged the overwhelming attention he has received regarding the potential for such a film, reflecting the public’s insatiable appetite for stories that blur the lines between heroism and villainy.
Two documentaries have already been announced, delving into the broader implications of Mangione’s alleged crime. One, directed by Stephen Robert Morse, will focus on the personal narratives of those involved, including Thompson’s family and Mangione himself, while exploring the controversial nature of private healthcare. The other, helmed by acclaimed director Alex Gibney, aims to contextualize the murder within a larger cultural framework, examining how society reacts to violence and crime. These projects reveal a growing trend in media to dissect the complexities of crime, raising ethical questions about the portrayal of real-life events and the responsibilities of filmmakers in representing sensitive subjects.
This fascination with Mangione extends beyond just his alleged actions; it speaks to a broader cultural phenomenon where individuals involved in notorious events become symbols of societal issues. The case invites discussions about the implications of private healthcare in the United States, particularly in the context of high-profile figures like Thompson. The murder of a corporate leader raises questions about the intersection of power, wealth, and morality, as well as the systemic issues within the healthcare industry that may contribute to such violent outcomes.
Furthermore, the public’s divided response to Mangione—some supporting his release while others vilify him—echoes a larger societal trend of polarization in the face of crime. The digital age has amplified this divide, allowing individuals to choose sides based on personal beliefs, experiences, and cultural affiliations. The phenomenon of “fan-casting” actors to play real-life criminals also reflects a troubling trend in which society grapples with its fascination for the macabre while simultaneously seeking to humanize those involved.
The implications of Mangione’s case extend beyond the individual, touching on issues of mental health, the impact of incarceration on identity, and the role of media in shaping public perception. The leaked letter reveals a moment of vulnerability and introspection, showcasing how even in the darkest places, individuals seek meaning and connection through cultural artifacts like music. This desire for engagement with popular culture can be seen as a coping mechanism, providing a temporary escape from the harsh realities of prison life.
As the narrative surrounding Mangione continues to evolve, it serves as a lens through which we can examine the complexities of crime, culture, and the human experience. The interplay between music, identity, and societal response to violence raises critical questions about how we understand and interpret the actions of individuals caught in the web of notoriety. The case of Luigi Mangione is not just about an alleged crime; it is a reflection of the cultural zeitgeist, revealing the intricate ways in which society grapples with morality, celebrity, and the consequences of violence.
Alleged murder suspect Luigi Mangione has revealed that he listened to Charli XCX and Taylor Swift‘s music while in prison.
Mangione, who was arrested in December for allegedly shooting and killing UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson outside of a Manhattan hotel, has turned into somewhat of a cultural phenomenon over the last year, earning himself a large base of fans, some campaigning for his freedom, while others praise his looks.
The suspect has spent the last 10 months at the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn, where he awaits charges for second-degree murder. He turned 27 in May, and now, a letter that he wrote to an undisclosed recipient reflecting on his birthday has been leaked online.
In the letter, Mangione reflects on the 27 things he’s grateful for – one of them being Taylor Swift’s ‘Cardigan’ that was later stuck out and replaced with Lil Durk‘s ‘Dis Ain’t What U Want’. Mangione wrote: “Last week, I downloaded a bunch of Taylor Swift and Charli XCX onto my tablet.”
He went on to explain: “I’ve never really listened to either of them, but some phony list of my favorite music circulated on social media… Rather than be a buzzkill and set the record straight, I figured I’d see what all the hype was about. So I’m walking laps on the top tier of my unit listening to ‘cardigan’ by TSwift, when one of the other inmates, ‘King,’ calls me over to see what I’m listening to. He scolds me for awhile, then replaces all my music. Now I listen to Lil Durk.”
You can read Luigi Mangione’s full letter below.
Luigi Mangione allegedly downloaded “a bunch” of Charli xcx songs onto his tablet in jail:
“Last week, I downloaded a bunch of Taylor Swift and Charli XCX onto my tablet. I’ve never really listened to either of them… I figured l’d see what all the hype was about. So I’m walking… pic.twitter.com/0tUkNBbX4l
— xcx source (@xcxsource) October 28, 2025
As a result of Mangione’s rise to infamy, the internet has begun fan-casting actors to portray the suspect in a hypothetical film. One name that is often brought up to play Mangione is Dave Franco, who earlier this year confirmed that he’s received countless pitches for a film.
When asked if by The Hollywood Reporter if anyone has compared Mangione to the actor, Franco’s wife Alison Brie quipped: “Anyone? Do you mean everyone?” Franco added: “I have never received more texts in my life about anything. Anyone who has my phone number has reached out about it.”
However, Brie and Franco were quick to clarify that “no official offers” have been made.
Talk of Franco’s potential casting as Luigi Mangione comes after two documentaries based on the murder suspect were announced in December. Stephen Robert Morse, known for his work on Netflix’s documentary Amanda Knox, is working on one that will focus on those directly involved in the murder, including Thompson’s family and Mangione himself. That production will also explore the controversial nature of private healthcare.
The other will come from the production companies Anonymous Content and Jigsaw Prods and the acclaimed director Alex Gibney, who has made documentaries about Scientology, WikiLeaks and Enron. That project will examine the wider context of the killing and how culture reacted to the events surrounding it.
The post Luigi Mangione listened to Charli XCX and Taylor Swift in prison before being confronted by an inmate appeared first on NME.
